PA Employer Has Burden to Show Job Unavailability in Labor Market Survey Case

We have discussed Labor Market Surveys (LMS) on this blog in the past.  This was one part of the sweeping 1996 amendments to the Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Act that insurance carriers across the State fought tooth and nail to have implemented.  The LMS (also known as Earning Power Assessment or EPA), removed the need for a PA workers’ compensation insurance carrier to show actual jobs available to an injured worker.  Instead, an injured worker’s benefits can be reduced, or eliminated, based on jobs that are generally available in the community.

Of note, before an insurer can proceed with the LMS process, under the provision of the Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Act (Act) which describes the LMS procedure, “If the employer has a specific job vacancy the employe is capable of performing, the employer shall offer such job to the employe.”  As noted in the prior blog entry, nonsensically, the injured worker had the burden to show that a job was available with the preinjury employer; the employer/insurer had no burden.

Recently, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania reversed the line of cases that placed this burden on the injured worker and restored some degree of justice by placing the burden back on the preinjury employer.  The case is George B. Thomas v. Sysco Foods (Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board) (we will call this Thomas 1, as there was a companion case notable for a different issue – coming soon to this very blog site!).

In Thomas 1, the Claimant was a forklift driver who suffered a significant injury, which resulted in an amputation of his lower left leg.  Bless their little hearts, the insurance carrier subsequently filed a petition to reduce ongoing wage loss benefits based on an LMS.  In that litigation, the vocational expert retained by the insurance carrier said he spoke to a woman at the preinjury employer who said there were no jobs available within Claimant’s restrictions.  On cross examination, the vocational counselor admitted that he could not say what position the woman held, or even at which subdivision of employer for which she worked (The employer is a large multi-billion-dollar, multinational corporation).

After hearing the evidence, the Workers’ Compensation Judge (WCJ) denied the petition.  She found the testimony of the vocational counselor failed to prove there were no light duty jobs available to Claimant with the preinjury employer.  The WCJ said that the insurance carrier therefore could not meet its burden.

Upon appeal, the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board (WCAB) reversed the decision.  Citing the established precedent, the WCAB found that the WCJ placed the burden incorrectly.  Under existing law, the employer had no burden to prove the nonexistence of a light duty job.  Instead, a burden for the employer is only triggered when the injured worker provides evidence of an open position.  This decision was affirmed by the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania then accepted the appeal and reversed the decision of the WCAB, finding that the WCJ was, indeed, correct.  First, the Court reviewed the decision by the Commonwealth Court in Rosenberg, which created the prior precedent (and is discussed in the above-referenced blog entry).  Note that Rosenberg was a 4-3 decision, so a close call.  Essentially, the Rosenberg decision found that statutory construction should give more of a burden to a party who can prove a fact, rather than one who would need to prove the nonexistence of a fact.

In its analysis, the Supreme Court then stated that the Act is silent on who has the burden in this situation, requiring statutory interpretation.  Citing prior case law, the Court noted, “Of particular relevance in this matter, we are mindful that the WCA was intended to benefit the injured employee, and, therefore, must be construed liberally in the employee’s favor in order to effectuate its humanitarian objectives.”

The Court then dealt with the tension between the normal process of assigning the burden to the party trying to prove a fact, rather than one trying to prove a negative, while also considering the nature and intent of the Act, and the particular aspects of this situation.  Significant in this analysis was the relative ability to access the information to be proven.  As the Court noted, “No reasonable person can dispute the conclusion that an employer bears ‘superior knowledge and access to evidence’ regarding its own employment capabilities.”  The Court observed that, in this situation, the proving of a negative is not a large burden to an employer.  “An employer under this rule would be perfectly justified in relying on any one of its human resources employees’ testimonies that there are no jobs available, and a WCJ may find that testimony sufficient to satisfy this obligation.”  This, said the Court, better reflects the intentions of the Act than having an injured worker need to rely on external sources, or the opposing party (who would have a large incentive to not cooperate), to provide the injured worker with timely and accurate information.

The Court then concluded:

“In light of the foregoing, we reiterate that, as part of its burden of proof to establish earning power under Section 306(b)(2) by a preponderance of the evidence, an employer must prove the nonavailability of a suitable position within its workforce. Consequently, we overturn Rosenberg and the cases that followed, to the extent they determined that a claimant bears the burden of proof with respect to establishing the availability of a job at their employer, including the Commonwealth Court’s memorandum decision in the case sub judice. Accordingly, we reverse the order of the Commonwealth Court, and remand for the reinstatement of the WCJ’s order.”

As attorneys who represent injured workers throughout the Southeastern and Central parts of the State of Pennsylvania, we applaud the efforts of the attorneys involved, and the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania for putting an end to the unfair situation.

Contact Information